Portrait of Theo Grant Season 4 · Episode 143
Leadership up close

How to give feedback people actually hear

Engineering leader Theo Grant shares the one-on-one format he uses with 60 engineers, and why most feedback fails before the first sentence.

GuestTheo Grant — VP of Engineering
Episode 143 59 min Hosted by Jordan Hayes
Episode 143 How to give feedback people actually hear
0:00 58:44

Demo player — no audio file is connected to this episode yet. Add an audioUrl to the episode's frontmatter to enable playback, or listen on one of the platforms below.

Show notes

Theo Grant has given — and received — a lot of feedback. Over twelve years of managing engineering teams, he has developed a simple, repeatable format that he credits with changing the culture of his organisation.

Jordan and Theo walk through that format in detail, with real examples, and talk about the harder cases: feedback for senior people, for your own manager and for yourself.

What we cover

  • Building trust before you need it
  • The observation–impact–request structure
  • The 48-hour rule
  • How to make one-on-ones genuinely useful

Key takeaways

  1. Feedback lands when the relationship is already in credit.
  2. Theo separates observation, impact and request into three distinct sentences.
  3. Most feedback is too late — he aims for within 48 hours.
  4. Ask for feedback on your feedback.

Timestamps

  • Introduction
  • Why most feedback fails
  • The three-sentence format
  • Running better one-on-ones
  • Feedback for your own manager
  • Listener questions

About the guest

Portrait of Theo Grant

Theo Grant

VP of Engineering

Theo Grant leads a 60-person engineering organisation at a developer tools company. He has managed teams for twelve years and writes a popular internal handbook on feedback and one-on-ones that has been adopted by several other companies.

More conversations on leadership up close.

All episodes
Portrait of Elena Marquez Episode 146 49 min
Life beyond work ·

The quiet art of managing burnout

Psychologist Elena Marquez on spotting exhaustion before it spreads through a team, and what managers can do on Monday morning.

with Elena Marquez
Portrait of Priya Nair Episode 148 63 min
Starting from zero ·

Why the best ideas start as side projects

Priya Nair on building a 40-person design studio from a weekend hobby — and why she still protects time for projects that might go nowhere.

with Priya Nair
Portrait of Daniel Okafor Episode 147 55 min
Entrepreneurship ·

Saying no to funding, twice

Daniel Okafor explains why he bootstrapped his logistics software company to $8M in revenue instead of taking venture capital.

with Daniel Okafor
Portrait of Marcus Lee Episode 145 67 min
Creative process ·

Writing every day for ten years

Novelist Marcus Lee on routine, rejection and the 3,000-word mornings that produced four books and one very large drawer of drafts.

with Marcus Lee
Portrait of Hannah Brooks Episode 144 51 min
Career ·

Leaving a dream job at the top

Hannah Brooks on walking away from a VP role to start over at 41, and how she made the decision with incomplete information.

with Hannah Brooks

Have a story like this? Be our next guest

We read every pitch and reply within two weeks if it's a fit for an upcoming season.